Supreme Court allows academic Ali Khan Mahmudabad, who is under probe over his Operation Sindoor posts, to continue writing

Supreme Court Allows Academic Ali Khan Mahmudabad to Continue Writing Amid Investigation

The Supreme Court of India has ruled in favor of academic and historian Ali Khan Mahmudabad, permitting him to continue his scholarly writings while an investigation into his controversial Operation Sindoor social media posts remains underway. The decision comes after Mahmudabad, a well-known commentator on Indian politics and history, sought judicial protection to uphold his academic freedom amid legal scrutiny.  

Authorities had initiated a probe into Mahmudabad’s posts related to Operation Sindoor, a term that stirred heated debates online over its alleged political implications. While investigators raised concerns about possible violations, Mahmudabad maintained that his writings were academic exercises protected under the right to free expression. A bench led by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud ruled that restricting his work during the investigation would amount to an "unnecessary curb on intellectual freedom," emphasizing that academic discourse should not be stifled without compelling justification.  

The court clarified that the investigation would continue independently but barred any interference with Mahmudabad’s research and publications. Free speech advocates celebrated the verdict as a reinforcement of constitutional rights, while some critics argued that the probe should have imposed stricter conditions. Mahmudabad’s legal team welcomed the decision, calling it a victory for scholarly expression.  

The ruling sets an important precedent in balancing legal inquiries with the protection of intellectual freedom in India. Authorities have been directed to expedite the investigation without disrupting Mahmudabad’s academic work. As the case progresses, observers are keenly watching its implications for future debates on free speech and academic independence in the country.